Separate symptoms from causes
A slow month-end close or unreliable report does not, by itself, establish that an ERP must be replaced. Map the steps involved, identify where delays arise and ask whether the problem sits in configuration, data, integrations or the surrounding process.
Check the platform’s boundaries
Review vendor support, security requirements, supported interfaces and essential capabilities. An unsupported product or a fundamental functional gap may make replacement necessary. Keep those constraints distinct from issues that targeted changes could resolve.
Compare complete options
Compare a focused improvement with a replacement using the same assumptions. Include implementation, data preparation, integrations, training, support and disruption. Make estimates explicit and test the highest-risk assumptions.
Run a measurable trial
Choose one process with a clear owner. Record the current time, errors and manual steps. Trial a change and use the result to inform the wider decision.